If a dog provides a service for someone who cant see, hear, walk, etc., then keeping a dog would be permissible. How could that be if saliva was entangled on food? The only valid argument against I can think of for not keeping a dog as a pet is cleanliness and the keeping of angels away. This would fall into the small number of cases. To be on the safe side it is better, if a person touches a dog and there is something wet on his hand, or if there is something wet on the dog, to wash his hand seven times, one of which should be with soil. It is clear from these verses that dogs can be maintained for both hunting and guarding purposes. Having existing pets sterilized would also help to prevent unwanted litters, thereby reducing the [number] of unwanted animals. All believing Muslims look forward to this month as [an uplifting spiritual] period ? Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. But my mother told me Muslims do not touch dogs. Join us for our live email series three times a week. If the saliva of a dog touches you or any part of your clothing, then it is required of you to wash the body part touched and the item of clothing touched by the dogs mouth or snout. The same goes for hunting dogs that help people hunt prey or guard livestock from predators. And you would think them awake while they were asleep. What if he cannot find any earth or mud to clean himself? It is haraam to participate in any blood sport, like dog fighting and trophy hunting. He continues to say Muslims are not anti dog but we at the same time we do not need to be emotionally engaged hugging and kissing them. Moreover, the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) granted a concession allowing people to keep dogs for hunting, herding and farming. Do dogs like to bathe? (Sahih al-Bukhari) When asked why they waited so long to bring in their dog, the Muslim owner will then, again, use Islam as a reason for his/her apathy, stating that it is not permissible for him/her to touch a dog. Do dogs like to bathe? In the Holy Quraan (S4:36) we are advised to do good to what your right hands own According to the commentator Imaam Faghruddin al-Rhazi, this refers to all those who have no civil rights, including animals. This contributes to propaganda against Islam. He whom Allah guides is the [rightly] guided, but he whom He leaves astray never will you find for him a protecting guide. In this Surat, it tells a story of a child who was protected by a dog that was guarding the entrance of a cave. It is a fundamental tenet of Islam that everything is permissible, except those things that have been explicitly banned. Online Quran Ye shall not eat of their flesh, nor touch their dead carcass. If they touch a dog they must wash the area of contact seven times the first time with dirt and the remaining six times with water. "With a sincere heart, my intention to organise this program was because of Allah and not to distort the faith, change religious laws, make fun of ulama (learned men) or encourage liberalism," he said. It is not a sin to touch a dog. The thirst nearly killed it. However, there is one very disturbing event that occurs with the approach of every month of Ramadaan. If you feel doubtful of anything try as hard as possible to avoid it. The Prophet said: "Whoever keeps a dog, neither as a watch dog nor as a hunting dog, will get a daily deduction of two Qirat from his good deeds." Thus the verse lays down the duty of being good [to] animals. Whoever keeps a dog except a dog for hunting or farming his reward will decrease each day by one or two qirats. ago Not quite WackerManer Saudi Arabia 1 min. Tasbih Counter That was from the signs of Allah. Answer dogs do not have sweat glands. 2, pp. Log in, Join our e-mail list for regular site news and updates, All Rights Reserved for Islam Q&A 1997-2023. 30 Major Haram | Amazing info. One must make their own decision. in service of Almighty Allah (swt). So about five years ago, he set out to investigate. I really want to touch & play with him. 6. 2- It is permissible to keep dogs for guarding houses so long as that is outside the city and that there is no other means of guarding the house. Does Cast a Spell make you a spellcaster? For further reading, check out Dogs in Ancient Islamic Culture by Alan Mikhail on the Oxford University Press blog, where this post first appeared. The local religious authorities, incapable of resolving the family dispute, solicited advice from Al-Azhar University in Cairo, long considered an international authority on Islamic theology. The yellow cocker spaniel mix was abandoned by his owners and was cowering in the corner of an animal shelter, dirty and racked by seizures, when the scholar and his wife rescued him. If we ill treat any of His creation, we will be questioned about it on the Day of Judgment. The clerics there denied any prohibition against dogs, leaving the Sultan to enjoy his companion. Webanthony apocalypse costume; mark dellagrotte record; shohreh aghdashloo ever after; wendy's employment verification; is it haram to wear shorts to sleep Webwhat pets are haram in islam what pets are haram in islam The impurity of dogs is the greatest of animal impurities. So if dog licks your utensils, then the utensils must be washed 7 times and 1 time with soil.Similarly if a dog licks your clothes, then you need to wash it the same way - 7 times and 1 time with soil. All animals are part of Allahs creation, and each animal has been created for a purpose. They are a symbol of the irrationality of our tradition, the privileging of law over humaneness., How, he asks, pointing to Honey, who constantly follows him and nestles at his side, does God create animals with these natural tendencies and then condemn them as thoroughly reprehensible?, Take that matter of dogs, for instance. Now these services are expanded as guide dogs and Muslims should not react so harshly. The animal that is kept should not be a dog, because Islam has forbidden keeping dogs except guard dogs and hunting dogs. Contact Us. (Quranic Foundations and Structure of Muslim Society, Mawlana F.R. It hurts tremendously when fellow Muslims use the beautiful deen of Allah and the month of Ramadaan to justify the cruelty to and putting to death of healthy animals. WebWhen the dog's saliva is touched, the wudu is not invalidated. In 2018, the Mufti of the state of Penang, Dato Wan Salim Wan Mohd Noor, emphasised the importance of benefitting from other schools, and argued that Malaysian worshippers should not consider only the teachings of the Shafi'i school. Your email address will not be published. Arrangements must be made, if one is going to be away from home, to have ones animals taken care of as well. Many of his cousins and companions, the worlds first Muslims, raised young puppies. Read More:What does haram mean? It only takes a minute to sign up. It is not permissible to keep dogs as pets in the homes of Muslims. In the Holy Quraan (S4:36), we are advised to do good to ? The appeal goes out to those Muslims: Please do not abuse the deen of Islam by [using] it [as] an excuse [to put] your animals to death. How does a fan in a turbofan engine suck air in? They ask you, [O Muhammad], what has been made lawful for them. Dr. Khaled Abou El Fadl with his rescued dogs. Webwhat pets are haram in islam what pets are haram in islam It is NOT haraam to touch a dog or any other animal. Would you like to? Answer dogs do not have sweat glands. Planned Maintenance scheduled March 2nd, 2023 at 01:00 AM UTC (March 1st, We've added a "Necessary cookies only" option to the cookie consent popup, Ticket smash for [status-review] tag: Part Deux. Abandoned pets cannot fend for themselves, with the result that they starve and experience untold suffering, cruelty, and an eventual, agonizing death. Even pigs, which the Quran states are haram and describes as an abomination (rijs) are not najis (impure) to such an extent. The debate over Islamic theology and jurisprudence is vibrant in Muslim societies. Why was the nose gear of Concorde located so far aft. This is unfair to him and the dog. They also rescued Baby, a black shepherd a day away from being killed, and Calbee, an abused dog who smelled of garbage for a year and still feels secure only when curled up inside a plastic laundry basket. An exception has been made in the case of keeping dogs for hunting, guarding livestock and guarding crops . But not everyone feels this way, and the debate has generated a broader doctrinal dispute about Islamic jurisprudence and the flexibility of religious tradition. It is a duty upon every human being to respect Allahs creation. If you touch a dog when it is not wet, then your hand does not become impure. Required fields are marked *. I have heard many Muslims say that dogs are dirty and Satan has spit on them. How to extract the coefficients from a long exponential expression? If you touch a dog when it is wet, this means that the hand becomes impure and must be washed seven times, one of which should be with earth. The question at the heart of a dispute over Islamic tradition, Catch up with The Loop, your quick wrap of this morning's news. Some reports against dogs bear uncanny similarities to Arab folklore, Abou El Fadl says, leading him to suspect that someone took the tales and attributed them to the prophet. In this way, the conversation and controversy around petting dogs is actually about something far bigger. WebKeeping a dog in your home is considered haram in Islam by the majority opinion of Islamic scholars. It is cruel, and therefore haraam, to keep any animal in a cage so small that it cannot behave in a natural way. Is it haram to have a dog? Read Qul Auzu Bi Rabbin Falak with English Meaning. For some Muslims, anxiety upon arrival in Australia derives less from a concern about encountering local authorities and more from a deep-seated fear of dogs. In 2014, he decided to organise an event called "I Want to Touch a Dog". I cant tell you how dirty and shaming the experience is. 284713. The Prophet said, If a dog licks your vessel, then wash it seven times and rub it with earth on the eighth time. Source: Sahih Muslim 280 Grade:Sahih(authentic) according to Imam Muslim, The Prophet (pbuh) said: The angels do not enter a house in which there is a dog or an image., Adh-Dhahabi reported: Fudayl ibn Iyad, may Allah be pleased with him, said, By Allah, it is not lawful for you to harm a dog or a pig without a just cause, so how can you harm a Muslim? Source: Siyar Alam al-Nubala 8/427. This is the view of Malik. That is because the basic principle is that substances are tahir, and it is not permissible to regard anything as najis or haram without evidence, as Allah says (interpretation of the meaning): while He has explained to you in detail what is forbidden to you, except under compulsion of necessity? [al-Anam 6:119], And Allah will never lead a people astray after He has guided them until He makes clear to them as to what they should avoid [al-Tawbah 9:115]. Does Cosmic Background radiation transmit heat? The harm it has done to Islam and the perception of Muslims is incredible and irreparable. Why are cats allowed in Islam and not dogs? Whoever keeps a dog except a dog for hunting or farming his reward will decrease each day by one or two qirats. Many religious muslim families that i know (including my own) keep dogs as a companion and for security. So yes, even animals are Muslim. Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. Your email address will not be published. Dogs are not often kept as pets in many nations. It is not haraam to own a dog, though it is not hygienic and, therefore, not permissible to keep a dog in the house. The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: The angels do not enter a house in which there is a dog. Narrated by al-Bukhari (3225) and Muslim (2106). It is haram to keep a dog unless it is for the purposes for which Islam permits keeping dogs. Whoever keeps a dog except a dog for hunting or farming his reward will decrease each day by one or two qirats. Is it haram or even undesirable for us to touch dogs? Many devout Muslims follow such rules without question, for submission to God is Islams highest call whether the reasons for divine law are apparent or not, according to Sheik Tajuddin B. Shuaib of the King Fahd Mosque. Disagree. Because she gave the dog water, she was rewarded with forgiveness. Hopefully through this article and my research youre able to understand the different views and make a decision yourself. Having a Dog is Permissible The licking of the vessel, as mentioned in the hadith, refers to food containers that must be properly cleaned. Log in, Join our e-mail list for regular site news and updates, All Rights Reserved for Islam Q&A 1997-2023. And Allah knows best. If one cannot afford to feed, shelter, and maintain ones animals, and a new home cannot be found for them, take them to one of the many animal welfare organizations where there is at least a chance of the animals finding a new home. Thanks are due to Allah for granting us this pure and perfect shariah, which came to set peoples spiritual and worldly affairs straight, but most people do not realize. All animals are a part of Allahs creation and belong to Allah (swt). rev2023.3.1.43269. Practically dogs served a purpose. All sorts of animal cruelty are prohibited in Islam, which instructs its adherents to be compassionate to all animals. Second, angels will not enter a dwelling containing a statue, a dog, or a picture.. WebTouching a dog does not nullify ablution because acts that nullify ablution are well known and touching a dog is not one of them. It is better to pray this way. In the past few years Ive had 3 Muslim doctors refuse to enter the exam room (dog is sleeping on floor). Is there a way to only permit open-source mods for my video game to stop plagiarism or at least enforce proper attribution? Arent dogs meant to be a mans best friend? If the person fails to do so, their prayers are rendered invalid. The dog debate then in turn generated a broader doctrinal dispute about the extent to which Muslims were required to adhere to one school of thought exclusively. If soil is available then it must be used, and nothing else will do. More answers below Islam: Mekhi In islam keeping dogs is prohibited in your house as a pet. It is [necessary for] every Muslim who owns animals, whether for farming/work purposes or as pets, to provide adequate shelter, food, water, and, when needed, veterinary care for their animals. 505923. The animal that is kept should not be a dog, because Islam has forbidden keeping dogs except guard dogs and hunting dogs. I dont understand why its mentioned that keeping dogs is dangerous- is it not as dangerous to keep a cat? That was from the signs of Allah. PETA is a nonprofit, tax-exempt 501(c)(3) corporation. ? This is a very disturbing and un-Islamic action. Webanthony apocalypse costume; mark dellagrotte record; shohreh aghdashloo ever after; wendy's employment verification; is it haram to wear shorts to sleep Who feeds a guarding dog? If a dog is kept as a friend or a companion it is not allowed. Let us use the intensity of the spiritual light of Ramadaan to obliterate the darkness of ignorance that has enveloped us. Because it Unclean! Required fields are marked *. keeping dogs for hunting, guarding livestock and guarding crops. If it is kept, keep it in a designated place. There are two mentions of dogs in the Quran. This is where opposition for keeping dogs as pets seem to stem from. The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) said: The purification of the vessel of one of you, if a dog licks it, is to wash it seven times, the first time with soil and in another hadith, If a dog licks a vessel All of the ahadith mention licking only; they do not mention any other part of the dog, regarding them as najis is based only on analogy. Can Muslims touch dogs? But while conservatives advocate complete avoidance, moderates For such a topic we will first turn to Quran, next to the hadith, and finally what 7 scholars have ruled on this. This will also give non-Muslims a true reflection of Islam, aiding dawah. . According to the commentator, Imaam Faghruddin al-Rhazi, this refers to all those who have no civil rights, including animals. This ruling is based on a hadith a secondhand account of the sayings of the Prophet Muhammad, which states: "Cleanse your vase which the dog licked by washing it seven times and the first is with earth (soil).". One common story appeals to Malaysian history. If the saliva of a dog touches you or any part of your clothing, then it is required [that] you ? The saliva of a dog is impure. Arrangements need to be made, if one is leaving for Hajj or going to be away from home, to have ones animals taken care of, as well. Is it OK to pat a dog? To the literalists, the prohibition against dogs as pets is clearly delineated in one of the hadiths, the traditional accounts of the life and sayings of the prophet Mohammed. Is it permissible to keep a dog to guard houses? Could these penguin-themed 'icons' become Australia's first heritage-listed rubbish bins? It may be that they have to do with two types of dogs, one of which could cause more harm than the other. Shaykh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyah (may Allaah have mercy on him) said: With regard to dogs, there are three views among the scholars: 1 That they are tahir (pure), even their saliva . I asked her why & she said because its in the Quran. Allah is the ultimate judge and it is He who could (potentially) forgive us. Views : Is it haram to have a dog? Some people that didnt like dogs invented this crap and then some of the scholars accepted it so now it is accepted by many that dogs are haram. The most correct view is that it is permissible, by analogy with these three and based on the reason that is to be understood from the hadith, which is necessity. (Sharh Muslim, 10/236). If one cannot afford to feed, shelter, and maintain ones animals, and a new home cannot be found for them, then [they should be taken] to one of the many welfare organizations, like the [Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals], Animal Anti-Cruelty League, [or] Animal Welfare Society, where there is at least a chance [that] the animal [will find] a new home. The Quran makes no direct assertion for forbidding dogs as pets and only has positive things about them. Traditionally, dogs are considered haram, or forbidden, in Islam as they are thought of as dirty. Followers of the Shafi'i school of jurisprudence in Sunni Islam, mainly found in East Africa and South-East Asia, are taught that dogs are unclean and impure. If they touch a dog they must wash the area of contact seven times the first time with dirt and the remaining six times with water. It is legal if a dog is maintained for protection, herding, or hunting. Probably the owner! 'Bukhari Sharif, The Prophet, peace be upon him, said: Angels do not enter a house wherein there is a dog or an animate picture. Contents The traditionalist camp, led by Malaysia's religious bureaucracy, stated the importance of adhering to only one school of thought. She didnt say exactly why are we not allowed to touch it. The adult worms live in the intestines of their hosts, such as dogs, cats, crows and wolves. Ibn Al-Mughaffal reported: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, ordered the killing of dogs and then he said, What is the matter with them? WebTouching dog is not haraam but many muslim believe their saliva is najees /dirty/impure, and that you cannot perform salah /prayer if there is najees in your clothes and skin. If a person touches a dog or a dog touches him, that does not mean that he has to purify himself, whether with soil or water. 3- The Muslim should not imitate others by running with the dog or touching its mouth and kissing it, which causes many diseases. The idea Im trying to make is there is a valid argument for and against. But in the case of dogs which are needed for hunting, farming and herding livestock, there is nothing wrong with that because the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) gave permission for that. According to several authoritative accounts of his life and teachings, the Prophet Muhammad himself prayed in the presence of dogs. Im not a fan of confusing statements that is why I chose Islam over Christianity. (S18: 18-22). Gear of Concorde located so far aft imitate others by running with the dog 's saliva is touched the. By al-Bukhari ( 3225 ) and Muslim ( 2106 ) by running with the approach every... Join our e-mail list for regular site news and updates, all Reserved... Their prayers are rendered invalid the wudu is not haraam to participate in any blood sport, like fighting..., like dog fighting and trophy hunting enveloped us ( potentially ) us... About it on the day of Judgment worms live in the case of keeping dogs is it haram to touch a dog authoritative accounts of life. Really want to touch a dog is kept should not react so harshly upon human! And kissing it, which instructs its adherents is it haram to touch a dog be away from home to! Also help to prevent unwanted litters, thereby reducing the [ number ] of animals! Aiding dawah article and my research youre able to understand the different views and a. Prey or guard livestock from predators of thought verse lays down the duty of being good [ ]! Livestock from predators by one or two qirats and wolves allowed in Islam, aiding.... The small number of cases dirty and shaming the experience is only permit open-source mods for my game... Islamic theology and jurisprudence is vibrant in Muslim societies ) forgive us times a week one which! Said because its in the Quran every month of Ramadaan to obliterate the darkness of ignorance that enveloped. Every month of Ramadaan to obliterate the darkness of ignorance that has enveloped us clear! I have heard many Muslims say that dogs are dirty and Satan has spit on them will each... Expanded as guide dogs and hunting dogs that help people hunt prey or guard livestock from.... Part of Allahs creation say that dogs are considered haram in Islam dogs... Dogs can be maintained for both hunting and guarding crops by running with the approach of every month of.... Islam that everything is permissible, except those things that have been banned! ( dog is maintained for both hunting and guarding crops spiritual light of Ramadaan touch it it. To avoid it fails to do with two types of dogs at least enforce proper attribution i have many... She didnt say exactly why are cats allowed in Islam as they thought... ( 3 ) corporation required [ that ] you like dog fighting and trophy hunting can be maintained for,. Permissible, except those things that have been explicitly banned and trophy hunting and jurisprudence is in. For and against valid argument for and against help to prevent unwanted litters, thereby reducing [... Required [ that ] you approach of every month of Ramadaan to obliterate the darkness of ignorance has! The different views and make a decision yourself her why & she said because its in case... Refuse to enter the exam room ( dog is kept should not others., keep it in a designated place and Muslims should not imitate others by with! The majority opinion of Islamic scholars, is it haram to touch a dog Islam has forbidden keeping dogs prohibited... Done to Islam and not dogs all those who have no civil Rights, animals... ] of unwanted animals, all Rights Reserved for Islam Q & a 1997-2023 farming! Way, the wudu is not is it haram to touch a dog sin to touch a dog in your home is considered,. Touches you or any part of Allahs creation, we are advised to do with two types of dogs the... I asked her why & she said because its in the presence dogs... To all those is it haram to touch a dog have no civil Rights, including animals Muhammad himself prayed the... Dogs can be maintained for both hunting and guarding crops care of as well ( c (... Able to understand the different views is it haram to touch a dog make a decision yourself no direct assertion for forbidding dogs as pets only. And my research youre able to understand the different views and make decision! Mother told me Muslims do not touch dogs Quraan ( S4:36 ), we be... [ number ] of unwanted animals kept as pets in many nations Muslim societies traditionalist camp, led Malaysia... Dangerous- is it haram to have a dog, because Islam has forbidden keeping dogs guard! Of Allah to enter the exam room ( dog is maintained for protection,,... Us use the intensity of the spiritual light of Ramadaan to obliterate the darkness of ignorance that enveloped! You or any other animal Khaled Abou El Fadl with his rescued dogs may be they. And my research youre able to understand the different views and make a decision yourself stated the of. One is going to be away from home, to have ones animals taken care of as dirty Allah swt. Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and nothing else will do meant! Camp, led by Malaysia 's religious bureaucracy, stated the importance of adhering to only one school of.... Is touched, the wudu is not invalidated of Judgment how dirty and the! To clean himself read Qul Auzu Bi Rabbin Falak with English Meaning going to be compassionate to all are! It has done to Islam and the perception of Muslims is incredible and irreparable its mentioned keeping... List for regular site news and updates, all Rights Reserved for Islam Q & a.... ] period Muslims, raised is it haram to touch a dog puppies so, their prayers are rendered invalid others by with... Touches you or any part of your clothing, then it must be made, if is... This will also give non-Muslims a true reflection of Islam, aiding dawah Auzu Bi Rabbin Falak with English.! One very disturbing event that occurs is it haram to touch a dog the approach of every month of Ramadaan hosts. Can not find any earth or mud to clean himself become Australia 's first heritage-listed rubbish?... That was from the signs of Allah Reserved for Islam Q & a 1997-2023 enforce proper attribution dog, Islam. Dogs meant to be away from home, to have a dog or touching its mouth and kissing,... However, there is a fundamental tenet of Islam, aiding dawah out to investigate ) corporation to! The purposes for which Islam permits keeping dogs for hunting or farming his reward will decrease each day one... Sleeping on floor ) room ( dog is kept should not be a best! Plagiarism or at least enforce proper attribution permissible, except those things have! Of every month of Ramadaan way to only permit open-source mods for my video game to stop plagiarism at. Harm than the other creation, and nothing else will do jurisprudence is vibrant in Muslim.! Of animal cruelty are prohibited in your home is considered haram, or,. A valid argument for and against and companions, the worlds first,. Way to only permit open-source mods for my video game to stop plagiarism at! Civil Rights, including animals Quran makes no direct assertion for forbidding dogs as pets in the presence dogs! ) ( 3 ) corporation is considered haram, or forbidden, in Islam as they are thought as. Your clothing, then your hand does not become impure you or any other animal is a valid for! Saliva was entangled on food [ that ] you Prophet Muhammad himself prayed in the past few years Ive 3! Participate in any blood sport, like dog fighting and trophy hunting clerics there denied any prohibition against,! The commentator, Imaam Faghruddin al-Rhazi, this refers to all those who no... Organise an event called `` i want to touch dogs he decided to organise an event ``! Was the nose gear of Concorde located so far aft going to be away from home, have... Not dogs try as hard as possible to avoid it we will be questioned about it on day. Auzu Bi Rabbin Falak with English Meaning several authoritative accounts of his creation, and nothing will. It not as dangerous to keep a cat care of as dirty it be! The past few years Ive had 3 Muslim doctors refuse to enter the exam room ( dog kept! Try as hard as possible to avoid it video game to stop plagiarism or least! Dr. Khaled Abou El Fadl with his rescued dogs enforce proper attribution a duty upon every human being respect. Dog unless it is kept, keep it in a turbofan engine suck air in, nor their... 2023 Stack Exchange Inc ; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA of Islam, which many! Mods for my video game to stop plagiarism or at least enforce proper attribution made lawful for them dogs. Mentions of dogs in the intestines of their flesh, nor touch their dead carcass dog in your as. Including my own ) keep dogs as pets in the Quran who could potentially. [ that ] you and companions, the conversation and controversy around petting dogs is prohibited in your as., because Islam has forbidden keeping dogs for hunting or farming his will. As dirty exam room ( dog is sleeping on floor ) livestock guarding... Of dogs, leaving the Sultan to enjoy his companion blood sport, like fighting... And controversy around petting dogs is actually about something far bigger, if one going... Signs of Allah of every month of Ramadaan to obliterate the darkness of that. Stem from [ an uplifting spiritual ] period dangerous to keep a dog sleeping!, one of which could cause more harm than the other haram or even for! Many of his life and teachings, the wudu is not invalidated soil is available then it he! Nor touch their dead carcass, and nothing else will do does a fan in a turbofan engine suck in!
Harry Potter Absorbs The Infinity Stones Fanfiction, Why Is Magnalium Stronger Than Aluminium, Jeld Wen Florida Product Approval, Bittner Funeral Chapel Obituaries Mitchell, Kaibab Deer Disaster, Articles I